…full of sound and fury, signifying nothing…
Shakespeare
While not as melodramatic as Macbeth, there is a certain rhyme in everyday life that heightens our sense of the importance of the present even though our intellect tells us that ultimately only history weighs each day, with a large majority being unremarkable. The consternation felt by some investors and most market commentators in the first half of the first quarter was replaced by relative calm in the second half; a round trip full of ups and downs, only to end up basically where we began (see Chart 1). The recurring lesson, of course, is not to be too sensitive to short-term market gyrations, but instead to focus on the likely longterm destination. In fact, in early February, when the drum beat of fear was loudest, Goodreid posted a blog on our website titled “Trust the Math”. It emphasized the multi-decade progression of the growth of the economy and corporate profits, and concluded that the stock market, as a pricing mechanism, would no doubt follow.

But all of this volatility makes it more difficult for some to be committed investors. At one point in the quarter, the U.S. index had lost more than 10% of its value. In fact, the first quarter saw 26 trading days in which the S&P 500 Index moved by more than 1% in either direction. If it were to keep up that pace for the rest of the year, it would, by that measure, make 2016 the 6th most volatile year in the past 66 years (see Chart 2 below). The Canadian market was volatile as well, but ultimately fared better, rebounding in the first quarter to a 4.5 % advance, in keeping with our views that we wrote about in our Q4, 2015 report that a balanced approach would lead to alternating leadership and help protect portfolios.
If one were to ignore the daily movements of stock prices (as a long-term investor should), one might recognize the positive economic figures and the equity market gains in Q1/2016 and conclude – correctly – that a recovery is underway. Canada’s economy continued its ascent, growing modestly in January with almost all industries – including, crucially, both the resource and manufacturing sectors – chipping in. Inflation receded in February, led mainly by falling gasoline prices. Unfortunately, unemployment ticked up slightly in February, for the third straight month, rising to 7.3%. The U.S. economy logged its second consecutive year of 2.4% real GDP growth. While the unemployment rate did tick back up in March, this was mainly due to what is seen as a “good” reason: an increase in the labour market participation rate.

The U.S. has been generating, on average, more than 200,000 net new jobs per month for two years. Inflation also fell south of the border. Chinese economic growth, while falling below the 7% average of late, still managed a 6.9% increase for 2015. In fact one of the culprits of the quarter’s volatility was the economic results from China. As U.S.
Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen pointed out, “one concern pertains to the pace of global growth, which is importantly influenced by developments in China.” That 6.9% expansion last year is still the envy of the world, but technically, it was the slowest growth in a quarter of a century. In those 25 years, China has grown to become the second largest economy on the planet, but it cannot keep up the same rate of growth it enjoyed from a lower base. It is important to recognize that the source of Chinese growth is changing as well. The era of state-sponsored investment in infrastructure is being replaced by consumer-driven growth. This has dramatic investment implications and likely explains much of the current weakness in commodity prices.
But this, too, is a more precipitous drop than is warranted by the fundamentals. This index has now fallen below even its nadir during the Financial Crisis, when the globe did indeed enter a recession. Yet the largest economy in the world, the United States, is faring far better today than it was back then and the second largest, China, while slowing a bit as noted above, is still growing smartly and is much larger now than in 2008.

Regardless, as the world economy becomes ever more integrated, events in one country will spill over into others – especially when it concerns the two largest economies. To the extent that softer Chinese demand leads to lower imports or commodity prices or currency values, then, yes, we can expect some negative effects in both Canada and the U.S. But let’s be careful not to let that argument become exaggerated. The engine of U.S. growth remains 70% domestically driven.
Central banks around the world are striving to achieve a common outcome – stability, which for the foreseeable future means that both Canadian and U.S. equity markets have, as they say, “powerful friends in high places”. Additionally, the market is showing signs of differentiating between performing and underperforming companies, allowing stock pickers an ability to outperform.
After a year of following the lead of our U.S. portfolio, Goodreid balanced investors relied on the Canadian equity side to provide leadership in the first quarter of 2016. As always, our goal is to outperform benchmarks and competitor managers. We are confident that by relying on the disciplines that make up Goodreid’s strategy, we will, over time, achieve the goals and objectives of our clients.
Back